Yates County Real Estate Auction

Tuesday, November 25, 2025 1:00 PM EST

3450 E Sherman Hollow Rd; Penn Yan NY 14527

Join us for this great real estate opportunity! Whether you’re looking for a homestead project, investment property, or peaceful retreat, this property is full of potential.

Auction Contacts

Salesperson

Broker

Jay Martin

Keuka Lake and Land Realty

315-521-3123

315-536-7446

jay@jmartinauctions.com

Salesperson

Jay Martin

315-521-3123

jay@jmartinauctions.com

Broker

Keuka Lake and Land Realty

315-536-7446

Auction Notes

Open house Monday November 10th from 1PM to 3PM

Open house Tuesday, November 25th from 10AM to 1PM

Auction Terms

Online Bidding Info

No online bidding- come in person!

Print
Email

Description

Charming Farmhouse on 2.2 Acres – Penn Yan, NY 

A rare opportunity to own a piece of rural Finger Lakes charm! This 2.2-acre property in Yates County, located within the Penn Yan School District, features a 2,424 sq. ft. farmhouse built in 1900. With 4 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, the home is ready for remodeling, offering plenty of potential to restore its historic appeal.

The interior includes a formal sitting room with a bay window, a spacious living room, and a kitchen that opens to the dining area. You’ll also find large amounts of closet space throughout, a downstairs full bathroom, and a laundry room for convenience. The home is primarily carpeted and includes a full cellar and an unfinished mud room, giving you ample space for storage and future projects. Heated by hot water and a coal stove, with a private well and septic system, the home offers comfort and rural privacy.

Outside, the property features a pine grove and a large 60′ x 32′ bank barn, ideal for agricultural use, storage, or a workshop. Property has 2 carports off Yatesville Rd, and gravel driveway by the barn off E Sherman Hollow Rd.

School taxes: $960.00
County taxes: $1,154.00

wpChatIcon
wpChatIcon